30.12.2007

Led Zeppelin-kritiki

Objavljeno v Led Zeppelin avtor samokodela

Danes imajo Zeppelin-i vse najbolj prestižne glasbene nagrade!!Grammy-a za življensko delo, nagrado Ivor Novello za življensko delo(britanski Grammy), Polar music prize-enakovreden Nobelovi nagradi, so v Rock and roll dvorani slavnih in še bi lahko naštevali.Poleg tega so prodali 300 milijonov albumov in so po številu prodanih plošč na drugem mestu, takoj za Beatlesi.

V času ko so Zeppelin-i nastopali, pa so bili toliko pred svojim časom, oziroma takšna avantgarda, da so jih mnogi kritiki zavračali, danes pa so ostali zgolj še nekateri samooklicani(heh) internetni kritiki in spodaj je moj komentar na enega takšnega internetnega kritika, ki ima na svoji strani tudi možnost puščanja komentarjev.

Imena kritika ne bom omenil, ker piše bedarije,mogoče ga boste sami našli, drugače pa je ruski lingvist, ki ima očitno dovolj prostega časa, da objavlja glupe kritike.

Komentar na moj naljubši Zeppelin album in nasploh na moj naljubši album na svetu Led Zeppelin III:

Led Zeppelin III is my favourite Zep record and infact, my favourite record in the world and your review of it George, is manipulation and demagogy at it most powerful and most devastating!!!Page and Plant certainly didn’t have too fight lawsuits all the time, actually very rarely and even then the lawsuits very pretty much unargumented.The only reason that influenced Zep to vary their material, was the fact that their moto was ‘ever onwards’. They always explored new directions on every album and each one of them was an honest statement of the band at the time. I really don’t find any of the songs being similar to ‘Baby i’m gonna leave you’, but they are just as great!!! Led Zeppelin had unbeliveable songwriting magic and the song ‘Double trouble’ has no resemblance to ‘Since i’ve been loving you’ at all, except that they are both blues, so i guess there is a resemblance betwen ‘Hey jude and ‘Candle in the wind’ too, because they are both pop.’ Hat’s of to Roy Harper’ does have old blues lyrics, but the rest is Page/Plant magic. And the title is just a tribute to Harper, with the actuall song not having much to do with him.As far as Plants voice goes, his voice is very beautiful and emotional and not whiny at all. Maybre a bit on the tune ‘The song remains the same’ but not here!I think Plants voice has great emotional quality and what you write is just completely untrue. There is just so much passion in his singing in ‘That’s the way’ and ‘Tangerine’ and ‘That’s the way’ was written in the Welsh countryside after Page and Plant had a long walk and they sat down on a hill and Page strumed a few chords and Plant just sung it out. There is nothing particulary dark in these ballads, although they are very sad and the ahaha singing at the end of ‘Gallows poll’ has to be like it is because it’s the evil laughter of the hangman!!Friends shows the huge range of Plants great voice!! It’s not Zeps fault if eighties bands TRIED to copy them and those bands can’t make Zep generic. Those bands are generic heavy metal but NOT Zep who are an original hard rock band!!!!!!!Listen to how passionatelly Plant sings the backing vocals in ‘Tangerine’ and ‘That’s the way’, you know those descending harmonies, just wonderful!!!!!!!!!I’m glad you realised at least a bit that Zep members are intelligent people and that they wrote intelligent music and lyrics!!!!!!And just because they wrote ‘Whole lotta love’ it doesn’t mean they were ‘looking for fuckmeat’ like you said George.Let’s go to the songs: ‘Immigrant song’ is a great hard rocking opener that was inspired by Zeps tour in Iceland.Great drumming, imaginative lyrics, powerful singing with Plant wailing, blistering bass runs and Page rocking with that riff and there is a possitive anti-war message at the end!!Nice melody too!!’Friends’ is an eastern sounding song, with a great string arrangement, amazing acoustic ryhtm guitar and Plant singing how important good friends are, while Bonzo is doing a bit of tabla drums.’Celebration day’ has layers of guitar riffs and is very melodic with a powerful chorus and one of the greatest Page solos. ‘Since i’ve been loving you’ is my favourite song in the world and it just has everything in the greatest way possible. Beautifully sad melody, that is very strong in the choruses, fantastic and so sad and complex organ fills, nice bass pedals playing, Page playing subtle intro that gains power and turns into an amazing melody and he also plays a wonderful riff after each chorus and the chorus riff is also great. He also plays nice phrases in the verses and in the solo his hands are creating enourmous hurricans of notes that take the song into a sad wonderland!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!Plant’s singing is his best ever!!!!!Extremely powerful, emotional and honest and showing his three octave range!!Bonzo also adds fantastic fills!!’ Out on the tiles’ is a Bonzo showcase that has great riffs, nice lovingful lyrics, a great melody and amazing drumming ofcourse.’Gallows pole’ has acoustic guitar, bass, drums, mandolin, banjo, electric guitar in it, and it has mostly original lyrics, just some of the melody is taken from an old blues song.Tangerine is so melodically strong, that George had to find some sort of excusses for his idea, that the song is not good. Of corsurse the song is great and the slide solo is amazing and Plant’s vocal style is different here, isn’t it George?? ‘That’s the way’ has Plant’s poetic and introspective lyrics and a beautiful, tearful melody and guitar – mandolin struming gentleness.’Bron y aur stomp’ is a funny song about Plant’s dog, with great Page’s soloing on acoustic guitar, that is also very melodically strong and has a catchy chorus, like all songs on the album except ‘Hat’s of’ that is also quite melodic, but it doesn’t have a chorus and it’s extremely frenetic blues singing, together with a slide guitar. So George as you can see, it is a fantastic album, one of the greatest in rock history actually and obviously you are just jealous and full of prejudices about Zep and you are not willing to open your ears to great music, but it is also possible that you just percept music differently then people who like Zep, because you like The Beatles very much and the Beatles don’t have much going on instrumentaly , so perhaps you prefer such pop/rock which is allright, because The Beatles are fantastic, but perhaps you should try listening to Zep in a new way, because there are people like me, who love Zep and The Beatles and perhaps you could become one of them too!!!!!!!Oh and obviously, ZEP ARE A VERY MELODIC BAND!!!!!!!!!!!(10/10).

  • Share/Bookmark
 
Objavo lahko komentiraš, ali pa s svojega bloga pustiš trackback. RSS 2.0

14 komentarjev

  1. Molen pravi:

    >>Poleg tega so prodali 300 milijonov albumov in so po številu prodanih plošč na drugem mestu, takoj za Beatlesi.

    Vir?

    30.12.2007 ob 10:06

  2. Samo Kodela pravi:

    ej ne vem zdaj, ampak če misliš da jaz kot obsedeni fan rabim wikepedio pri Zeppelin-ih,

    pol pa ti rabiš banjo.

    drugač pa bom malo poiskal naokrog, itak imam jaz enih 250 milijonov od teh 300 milijonov albumov.

    30.12.2007 ob 10:48

  3. Samo Kodela pravi:

    ej to sem pa dejansko zdaj prek wikipedie našo, ampak sem že prej enkrat v draženskem listu prebral, heh.

    http://www.led-zeppelin.com/news/vh1_9.14.06.html

    30.12.2007 ob 10:51

  4. Samo Kodela pravi:

    ej ap stari Plantovemu psu je bilo ime

    Stryder!!!!!!

    30.12.2007 ob 10:52

  5. milan pravi:

    Saj so carji, ampak nekaj stvari bi pa lahko vedel.Na zahodni polobli je največ plošč prodal Barry White.Drugač pa obstaja en indijec,ki je prodal več plošč kot vsi našteti skupaj.Ma Indija pač eno miljardo ljudi, od tega je pa ene 20%kar premožnih.

    30.12.2007 ob 12:12

  6. Samo Kodela pravi:

    kdo pa je to štel, te plošče????

    mahatma ghandi????

    pa je bla to dobra muzika,

    al je bla teresa kolšek???

    30.12.2007 ob 12:34

  7. Samo Kodela pravi:

    a ti si reporter????

    30.12.2007 ob 12:35

  8. Samo Kodela pravi:

    pa dvajset procentov, to je 200 milijonov!!!

    30.12.2007 ob 12:35

  9. samokodela samokodela pravi:

    hoh, hoh, ho hoh hohohohoho hhohohohohohohohohohohohohohohohohohohohohohoh

    heh, hoh, heh, hoh, hihihieneis rdigndp0wefnjanjvns NMgkbngjeRNGJ; sfkl

    30.12.2007 ob 12:50

  10. samokodela samokodela pravi:

    pa jaz ne pišem tega bloga zahec, ampak da dokažem da sem najbolj pameten,

    se pravi bolj kot klošar brez posluha,

    ki je podnajemnik v stanovanju, katerega je solastnik.

    30.12.2007 ob 12:52

  11. milan pravi:

    A TEBE KEJ PREBAVA DAJE

    30.12.2007 ob 12:57

  12. prebaviteljica pravi:

    hahahah, skozi gužvo o Zeppelnih se sicer nisem prebila, ampak moja prebava pa je ob branju komentarjev začela nenormalno pospeševat :)

    30.12.2007 ob 13:03

  13. Molen pravi:

    Banja ali banja bi mi vsekakor prav prišla.

    Naj te ne skrbi sem js včeraj 400 milijonov plat od Damjana Murka nabavu. He he.

    30.12.2007 ob 13:52

  14. how to make money blogging pravi:

    Dude.. I’m not much into reading, but somehow I got to read many articles in your webpage. Its fantastic how interesting it is for me to visit you very often.

    16.09.2010 ob 07:50

Komentiraj

Za pisanje komentarjev morate biti prijavljeni.